Understanding Your Home's True Market Value
One of the most confusing aspects of selling a home is understanding its true market value. You might get three different valuations from three different sources—and they could all be "correct" for their specific purposes.
In this guide, we'll demystify home valuation by explaining how different professionals calculate your home's worth, what factors they consider, and why their numbers might not align.
Why Home Values Vary
Here's a common scenario: Your online estimate says $350,000. Your agent suggests listing at $375,000. An investor offers $280,000. Which number is right?
The answer: All of them—because each represents a different valuation purpose and methodology.
The 3 Types of Home Value
- 1.Market Value: What buyers are willing to pay in current conditions
- 2.Appraised Value: Official valuation for lending purposes
- 3.Investment Value: What investors will pay after factoring in costs and profit
Method 1: Comparative Market Analysis (CMA)
Who uses it: Real estate agents
A CMA compares your home to recently sold properties in your area with similar characteristics. Agents analyze 3-5 "comps" (comparable sales) and adjust for differences.
How It Works
Example: Your home is 1,800 sq ft, 3 bed, 2 bath, built in 2005.
Agent finds a similar home (1,750 sq ft, 3 bed, 2 bath, 2006) that sold for $340,000. They add $5,000 for your extra 50 sq ft and subtract $3,000 because your neighbor's home needs exterior paint. Adjusted value: $342,000.
Strengths & Limitations
✓ Strengths
- • Reflects current buyer demand
- • Uses recent, local data
- • Accounts for neighborhood trends
- • Free from your agent
✗ Limitations
- • Subjective adjustments
- • Agent may overvalue to win listing
- • Limited comps in unique areas
- • Doesn't account for hidden issues
Method 2: Professional Appraisal
Who uses it: Lenders, courts, and refinancing situations
A licensed appraiser conducts an in-depth property inspection and provides an official valuation report. This is the most objective method—appraisers have no financial stake in the outcome.
What Appraisers Evaluate
- •Property condition: Roof, foundation, systems (HVAC, plumbing, electrical)
- •Square footage & layout: Verified measurements, functional obsolescence
- •Comparable sales: Recent sales within 0.5-1 mile, adjusted for differences
- •Neighborhood factors: Schools, crime, amenities, future development
- •Market trends: Supply, demand, days on market, price per square foot
💡 Pro Tip: Appraisals typically cost $300-$500. Buyers usually pay for the appraisal when getting a mortgage, but sellers can order their own pre-listing appraisal to set realistic expectations.
Why Appraisals Can Kill Deals
If you accept a $400,000 offer but the appraisal comes in at $380,000, the lender will only finance $380,000 (minus down payment). The buyer must either:
- • Bring an extra $20,000 cash to closing, or
- • Renegotiate the price down, or
- • Walk away from the deal
Method 3: Investor Valuation (ARV Formula)
Who uses it: Real estate investors, wholesalers, house flippers
Investors use the After Repair Value (ARV) formula to determine the maximum they can pay while still making a profit.
The ARV Formula
ARV (After Repair Value) = $400,000
- Renovation Costs = $50,000
- Profit Margin (20%) = $80,000
- Holding Costs = $10,000
= Maximum Offer: $260,000
This is why investor offers are typically 30-40% below market value. They're not trying to lowball you—they're ensuring the numbers work for their business model.
When Investor Offers Make Sense
- ✓Your home needs major repairs you can't afford
- ✓You need to close in 7-14 days (job relocation, foreclosure, divorce)
- ✓You want to avoid showings, staging, and uncertainty
- ✓The carrying costs (mortgage, taxes, insurance) are draining you
Online Estimators: How Accurate Are They?
Zillow, Redfin, and Realtor.com use algorithms (called AVMs - Automated Valuation Models) to estimate home values based on:
- • Public records (square footage, bedrooms, bathrooms)
- • Recent sales data
- • Tax assessments
- • User-submitted updates
⚠️ Accuracy Warning
Zillow's own data shows their "Zestimate" has a median error rate of 7.49% for on-market homes and 8.16% for off-market homes. On a $300,000 home, that's a potential $22,000-$24,000 variance.
Online estimates don't account for: recent renovations, deferred maintenance, unique features, neighborhood micro-trends, or current market momentum. Use them as a starting point, not a final answer.
Factors That Impact Your Home's Value
1. Location (30-40% of value)
The old real estate saying "location, location, location" is true. You can change almost everything about a home except where it sits.
- • School district ratings (homes in top school districts sell for 20% more)
- • Proximity to amenities (parks, shopping, dining)
- • Crime rates and neighborhood safety
- • Future development plans (new highway? New shopping center?)
- • Lot position (corner lot, cul-de-sac, busy street)
2. Property Size & Layout (25-30% of value)
- • Square footage (price per square foot is a key metric)
- • Bedroom/bathroom count (3 bed/2 bath is the sweet spot)
- • Lot size (larger lots command premium in suburbs)
- • Functional layout (open concept vs. choppy floor plan)
- • Storage space (closets, garage, basement)
3. Condition & Upgrades (20-25% of value)
- • Age of roof, HVAC, water heater, appliances
- • Kitchen and bathroom updates (highest ROI)
- • Flooring condition (carpet vs. hardwood)
- • Curb appeal and landscaping
- • Recent renovations (but over-improvements don't always pay off)
4. Market Conditions (10-15% of value)
- • Buyer demand (low inventory = higher prices)
- • Interest rates (higher rates = fewer qualified buyers)
- • Seasonality (spring/summer are peak selling seasons)
- • Economic trends (job growth, recession fears)
The Bottom Line
Your home's "true value" depends on who's asking and why. An agent's CMA targets market value for listing. An appraiser provides lending value for mortgage approval. An investor calculates investment value for profitability.
The smartest approach? Get multiple valuations. Compare a CMA from 2-3 agents, consider an independent appraisal, and use online estimates as a sanity check. Then decide which selling path aligns with your priorities—speed, certainty, or maximum price.
Want to See All Your Options?
Propvera shows you side-by-side valuations across ALL selling methods—MLS listing, cash offers, and more—so you can make the best decision for your situation.
Get Your Free Assessment